Current:Home > MyFacing backlash over IVF ruling, Alabama lawmakers look for a fix -Zenith Profit Hub
Facing backlash over IVF ruling, Alabama lawmakers look for a fix
View
Date:2025-04-13 22:51:49
MONTGOMERY, Ala. (AP) — Lawmakers began scrambling for ways to protect Alabama in vitro fertilization services after multiple providers paused services in the wake of a state Supreme Court ruling that frozen embryos could be considered children under a state law.
Facing a wave of shock and anger from the decision, legislators prepared separate proposals in the House and Senate that would seek to prevent a fertilized egg from being recognized as a human life or an unborn child under state laws until it is implanted in a woman’s uterus.
Justices ruled last week that three couples who had frozen embryos destroyed in a mishap at a storage facility could pursue wrongful death claims for their “extrauterine children.” Justices cited sweeping language that the GOP-controlled Legislature and voters added to the Alabama Constitution in 2018 saying that the state recognizes the “rights of the unborn child.”
Senate Minority Leader Bobby Singleton, a Democrat, said Republicans helped create the situation in their push to enact some of the most stringent anti-abortion laws in the country. The result, he said, was eliminating a path for people to become parents.
“At the end of the day, the Republican Party has to be responsible for what they have done,” Singleton said.
Former President Donald Trump joined the calls for Alabama lawmakers to act Friday and said he would “strongly support the availability of IVF.”
State Republican lawmakers said they were working on a solution.
“Alabamians strongly believe in protecting the rights of the unborn, but the result of the State Supreme Court ruling denies many couples the opportunity to conceive, which is a direct contradiction,” House Speaker Nathaniel Ledbetter said.
Republican state Sen. Tim Melson, who is a doctor, said his proposal seeks to clarify that a fertilized egg is a “potential life” and not a human life until it is implanted in the uterus.
“I’m just trying to come up with a solution for the IVF industry and protect the doctors and still make it available for people who have fertility issues that need to be addressed because they want to have a family,” Melson said.
House Minority Leader Anthony Daniels, a Democrat, introduced legislation to clarify that a “human egg or human embryo that exists in any form outside of the uterus shall not, under any circumstances, be considered an unborn child” under state law.
“This is just the first step in unwinding this predicament our state has placed itself in,” Daniels said.
Melson said he was not surprised that the state is seeing unintended consequences from the constitutional language. Supporters said it was intended to block abortion if the states ever gained control of the issue. But opponents warned it was essentially a “personhood” measure that would establish “constitutional rights for fertilized eggs.”
Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey said the state wants to foster a culture of life and that includes “couples hoping and praying to be parents who utilize IVF.”
Alabama Attorney General Marshall does not intend to prosecute IVF providers or families based on the state Supreme Court ruling, Chief Counsel Katherine Robertson said in a statement.
The court’s ruling, treating the embryos the same as a child or gestating fetus under the wrongful death statute, raised questions about what legal liabilities clinics could face during IVF processes, including the freezing, testing and disposal of embryos. Three in vitro fertilization providers in Alabama paused their services in the aftermath of the ruling.
Gabby Goidel, who was days from an expected egg retrieval appointment, was told Thursday that her provider would not continue doing embryo transfers.
“I started crying,” said Goidel, who swiftly traveled with her husband to Texas to try to continue the IVF cycle with a provider there. The Alabama ruling is “not pro-family in any way,” Goidel said.
At the Fertility Institute of North Alabama, Dr. Brett Davenport said his clinic will continue providing IVF. But he also urged state policymakers to act and remove the uncertainty for providers.
“What we do could not be any more pro-life. We’re trying to help couples who can’t otherwise conceive a child,” Davenport said.
The court ruled only that embryos are covered under Alabama’s wrongful death statute, said Mary Ziegler, a legal historian at the University of California, Davis School of Law. The court did not say embryos had full constitutional rights, she said, or at least not yet.
“I think people in Alabama are rightly expecting that this is the tip of the iceberg though, and this ruling will lead to more down the road,” Ziegler said. She also said anti-abortion groups and politicians have been pushing to get some sort of ruling through the federal courts “that a fetus is a constitutional rights holder.”
“It’s not just about in vitro and it’s not just about Alabama. It’s part of this nationwide movement too,” she said.
veryGood! (44729)
Related
- San Francisco names street for Associated Press photographer who captured the iconic Iwo Jima photo
- San Francisco jury finds homeless man not guilty in beating of businessman left with brain injury
- Florida State's lawsuit seeking ACC exit all about the fear of being left behind
- Michigan State freshman point guard shot in leg while on holiday break in Illinois
- Tree trimmer dead after getting caught in wood chipper at Florida town hall
- Dunk these! New year brings trio of new Oreos: Gluten-free, Black and White, and new Cakester
- Ariana Grande Gives a Cute Nod to Boyfriend Ethan Slater With Her Holiday Decorations
- A possible solution to a common problem with EVs: Just rewire your brain
- Federal appeals court upholds $14.25 million fine against Exxon for pollution in Texas
- At a church rectory in Boston, Haitian migrants place their hopes on hard work and helping hands
Ranking
- The city of Chicago is ordered to pay nearly $80M for a police chase that killed a 10
- Alex Batty, British teen found in France after missing for 6 years, breaks his silence: I've been lying
- A Detroit man turned to strangers to bring Christmas joy to a neighbor reeling from tragedy
- Hermès scion wants to leave fortune to his ex-gardener. These people also chose unexpected heirs.
- 'Vanderpump Rules' star DJ James Kennedy arrested on domestic violence charges
- New app seeks to end iPhone-Android text color bubble divide
- Michigan State basketball freshman Jeremy Fears shot in leg in hometown, has surgery
- Furnace explosion at Chinese-owned nickel plant in Indonesia kills 13
Recommendation
Selena Gomez's "Weird Uncles" Steve Martin and Martin Short React to Her Engagement
Mega Millions winning numbers for Dec 22: Jackpot at $57 million after no winner Tuesday
Meet the dogs who brought joy in 2023 to Deion Sanders, Caleb Williams and Kirk Herbstreit
Yankees' Alex Verdugo ripped by Jonathan Papelbon after taking parting shots at Red Sox
Travis Hunter, the 2
Jets owner on future of Robert Saleh, Joe Douglas: 'My decision is to keep them'
Why you should watch 'Taskmaster,' the funniest TV show you've never heard of
Dixie Chicks Founding Member Laura Lynch Dead at 65 After Car Crash